hive_mind wrote:I've had excellent results from Kickstarters myself. Every game I've decided to fund has been a pretty good deal, both in components and gameplay. My only complaint is that a few of them have taken a bit longer to be delivered than I'd hoped (I'm looking at you Tasty minstrel games). Of course, these were the some of the best games of the lot, so i guess the extra time was worth it.
I have had excellent results as well but like anything else in the world, you usually do not pay for something that has not been playtested yet. I am not a fan of forking over money for an idea that has not been playetested to death to ensure the flaws are removed. Boardgames are no exception.
Alien Frontiers was a KS project and it did very well. I waited until it got to the gaming store though because I wanted to make sure it was playable.